As part of my research and study on this topic, I have been able to slowly get a handle on the phenomenal revolution that is occurring in e-research. The topic of federated searching, as both Rebecca and Cathy have alluded to, is possibly not at the point where it has become user friendly and accessible, when compared to other search engines at our disposal. Of course the reliable Google Scholar, advaced web searches, the use of a little knowledge of search engine math, and access to platforms such as PubMed etc.. has made research quite "specific and sensitive" (as Rebecca stated), without the use of federated searching. In order to understand the techno jargon involved, I have adopted a "hands on approach" to this topic by "googling" etc.. and even found a federated searching platform but as I had restricted access, it leads me to believe, that federated searching may not be designed for the individual user. My interpretation maybe totally wrong here, but I have made this assumption based on my experience so far. As far as the data repositories are concerned I can definitely see the benefits and have noticed the trend towards the completion of e-theses, but as Cathy pointed out, the extend to which collaboration can be supported through Access and Data Management systems is what appeals to me as well. I have been involved in a collaborative online project in the area of Tobacco Use Prevention and Cessation and the role of oral health professionals, which I will be using as the main focus of the first assessment task and my study so far has enabled me to expand my research in this area.
In closing, I would just like to mention that with a blink of an eye, I have spent 3 -4 hours on the net, just to get my head around a couple of the readings. Very time consuming for me but worthwhile... Just finding the time when students are around is almost impossible ...... Watch this space ........
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I think you have hit on a really important point Sophie. I too use google all the time when I want to find out about something. I suppose it depends on what type of information you are looking for. It is my experience that even Google scholar isn't the most efficient way for me to find research information about a topic I am studying. However, it is a great place to start if you want a feel for what is out there. Or if you just need background information, definitions etc. So long as students understand this distinction - at least as the search engines presently function -then I think google is extremely useful. But knowing what trust to place in the information you find is something that needs to be emphasized. And also how to attribute the information uncovered.
I also found what you did when I googled a bit on federated searching. It seemed that it was more a product aimed at libraries/institutions and for managing databases of information. However, the presentation at the conference did seem to be implying it could replace searches in multiple databases for individuals. A colleague of mine in the Cochrane Collaboration advises that the federated searches have been around for a few years but have not taken off in Cochrane so I guess there must be some real shortcomings.
Thanks Rebecca
Its so comforting to know that you share the same experiences as I do. I feel validated kowing that someone with your research background can relate to my perceptions.
Thanks and thanks for providing me with an insight into research from your own comments posted on your blog.
Post a Comment